The Top 5 Recruitment Challenges This Term

Introduction

Every school term brings new challenges for education recruiters. The pace of change in staffing needs is relentless, and agencies often find themselves juggling competing priorities: urgent cover requests, candidate turnover, compliance demands, and the ever-present weight of administration. What separates successful agencies from those that struggle is not whether these challenges exist — it’s how well they prepare for them and respond in the moment.

Below we explore the five most common recruitment challenges agencies are facing this term, and how the right systems and processes can turn obstacles into opportunities.

1. Last-Minute Bookings

Few industries move as quickly as education recruitment. A call at 7am for same-day supply cover is the norm, not the exception. Schools rely on agencies to fill gaps instantly, and hesitation can mean a lost placement.

The challenge is that traditional methods — phone trees, manual availability checks, and compliance folders — don’t move at the same speed. By the time recruiters confirm who’s free and compliant, another agency may have already secured the booking.

How to overcome it:
Agencies that invest in automation can respond within minutes, not hours. A CRM like MyTalent allows recruiters to see candidate availability and compliance status instantly, then send confirmations via SMS or email in just a few clicks. With speed built into the process, last-minute bookings transform from stress points into opportunities to shine.

2. High Candidate Turnover

Teaching staff often move on quickly — especially supply teachers who thrive on flexibility. High turnover forces agencies to spend more time recruiting new candidates instead of nurturing existing ones. Not only is this costly, it can also leave schools frustrated when familiar faces suddenly disappear.

How to overcome it:
Retention starts with engagement. Agencies that maintain contact between placements, offer regular check-ins, and make payroll seamless build loyalty. Data can also play a role: tracking assignment lengths, candidate satisfaction, and cancellation patterns helps recruiters identify at-risk staff before they leave. By focusing on retention as much as attraction, agencies create a more stable workforce and a stronger reputation with schools.

3. Compliance Bottlenecks

Compliance is non-negotiable in education recruitment. DBS checks, Right-to-Work documents, references, and safeguarding records are essential, but they’re also time-consuming. Manual processes create bottlenecks that delay placements and frustrate candidates who are eager to work.

How to overcome it:
The key is centralisation and automation. MyTalent CRM ensures all compliance records are stored in one place, with automated reminders for missing documents or upcoming renewals. Recruiters can filter candidates by compliance status at the click of a button, eliminating wasted time. The result is faster placements, reduced risk, and schools that trust your agency’s standards.

4. Limited Visibility of Demand

Many agencies operate reactively, responding to bookings as they come in. While necessary, this leaves little room for planning. Without clear visibility into demand patterns, agencies risk being caught off guard by seasonal spikes or sudden shortages.

How to overcome it:
Analytics provide the missing insight. By reviewing historical data, agencies can spot trends: which schools regularly need cover before exams, which branches experience peak demand in certain months, or which candidates are most reliable. Armed with this knowledge, recruiters can allocate resources more effectively, anticipate school needs, and position themselves as proactive partners rather than reactive suppliers.

5. Excess Admin

Recruiters join the industry to connect schools with great teachers — not to drown in paperwork. Yet for many, admin dominates the working day. From updating spreadsheets to chasing compliance documents, every small task eats into time that could be spent on building relationships.

How to overcome it:
Streamlined systems are the solution. A CRM reduces duplication by keeping all candidate and client information in one place. Automation handles repetitive tasks like sending reminders or processing timesheets. Instead of acting as administrators, recruiters can focus on what they do best: matching the right people with the right roles.

Conclusion

Education recruitment will always come with challenges. Last-minute bookings, turnover, compliance, visibility, and admin are part of the landscape. But with the right tools, these hurdles don’t have to hold agencies back.

MyTalent CRM is designed to tackle each of these issues head-on — from speeding up compliance and booking processes, to providing the analytics that give recruiters visibility and control. By embracing technology, agencies free themselves to focus on the heart of recruitment: people.

The challenges of this term are real, but they’re not insurmountable. With the right systems in place, they become stepping stones to stronger relationships, more efficient processes, and long-term growth.

News Details