Candidate Retention in January: How Agencies Can Keep Their Best Talent

Every January, schools and recruitment agencies face the same challenge: staff movement. New roles begin, contracts end, and many teachers and support staff reassess their career plans at the start of the year. For agencies, this can mean losing valuable candidates just when schools need them most.

That’s why retention is one of the most critical priorities for education recruiters in January. Agencies who keep their candidates engaged, valued, and supported during this period not only protect their pipelines — they strengthen their reputation with schools.

1. Why January Is a High-Risk Month

Fresh starts – many candidates take January as an opportunity to change roles or reduce hours.
Post-holiday fatigue – the return to term can feel overwhelming, especially for supply staff.
High demand from schools – absences and long-term vacancies spike, creating pressure on candidates and agencies alike.

Without a strong retention strategy, agencies risk losing their most reliable people just when demand is highest.

2. The Cost of Losing Candidates

Candidate drop-off isn’t just inconvenient — it’s costly:

Schools lose trust when familiar staff disappear.
Recruiters waste hours sourcing and vetting replacements.
Payroll and compliance workloads increase with every new starter.

Retention isn’t just about saving time. It’s about protecting consistency and credibility.

3. How Agencies Can Strengthen Retention

The agencies that succeed in January are the ones who:

Communicate clearly and often – regular check-ins show candidates they’re valued.
Match thoughtfully – sending staff to the right schools and roles keeps them motivated.
Guarantee payroll accuracy – nothing damages trust faster than late or incorrect payments.
Provide support and recognition – celebrating positive feedback makes candidates feel appreciated.

4. Building Loyalty Through Engagement

Retention is built on relationships. Candidates who feel seen, supported, and listened to are far less likely to leave. Agencies who build loyalty now enjoy smoother placements and stronger pipelines throughout the year.

How MyTalent CRM Helps Agencies Retain Talent

At MyTalent CRM, we’ve built our platform to help agencies strengthen candidate retention with:

Engagement dashboards showing which candidates are active, quiet, or at risk.
Automated communication tools to keep check-ins consistent.
Preference tracking to match candidates to the roles they want.
Payroll integration to ensure accuracy and build trust.

By combining smart systems with personal relationships, agencies turn retention from a risk into a competitive advantage.

Final Thought
January is a month of movement — but it doesn’t have to mean losing great candidates. Agencies who invest in retention now protect their pipelines, keep schools happy, and build a stronger foundation for the rest of the year.

👉 Discover how MyTalent CRM helps agencies keep candidates engaged and loyal

News Details